Mr. Shea alludes to "paper trails" in his article.
It really would not have occurred to me to treat an intellectual debate as if it were a KGB matter for investigation against enemies of the State.
But since Mr. Shea has suggested that he and Mr. Palm have embarked upon this approach........
Let me say that we have discovered some very interesting paper trails ourselves ;-)
Stay tuned.
Here' what I wrote on Shea's web site:
ReplyDeleteDoes the latest scientifically vetted evidence point to a special place for Earth in the universe, pace the Copernican and Einsteinian principles, or not? That's the issue, so what's all the insinuation and character attacks about? Is it now beyond the pale of morality and reason and Catholicism even to ask what the evidence is telling us? Are we back to the fideism of the 14th century Franciscans in their departure from the harmony of faith and reason of Aquinas?
It seems it's also taboo to ask what the evidence is telling us in other non-politically correct areas, such as how Building 7, never hit by a plane, came down at free fall speed--nay, actually turned to dust in front of all of us. No, we must just believe in the shadows the puppeteers display for us. How dare you step out of line! Catholics need to be better than this.
If it is now mandatory for Catholics to maintain that the naked emperor has clothes on, then we have lost our salt, and the world will continue in its path to destruction.
In any event, no man of reason should have anything to do with yours and Palm's "morality, reason, and faith," for they are counterfeit.
I posted a reply to the "Bullocks" video someone has offered in the combox with this link. It was swiftly deleted & I was blocked.
Deletehttp://galileowaswrong.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/Bullocks_Rebuttal-2.pdf
I'm sure he's not happy about the fact that most of the material people smugly post is addressed at GWW.
I just submitted the following reply to Thaddeus' comment on Shea's blog. It was immediately blocked and under the asterisks is what came up in the space where my reply would have been.
ReplyDelete"Very well said Thaddeus! I hope it is not deleted as was done to my previous comment and that of Rick DeLano, the producer of the movie documentary The Principle seen at www.theprinciplemovie.com. Mr. DeLano had pointed out a number of blatant and slanderous false assertions in Mr. Shea's article."
***********************************************************************************************
You do not have permission to post on this thread.
Needless to say, Dr. Kozinski, you have been memory holed!
ReplyDeleteI feel like "Magisterial Fundies" may have archaeological significance.
It is the place you can come to read what *actually* got posted on Mark Shea's blog ;-)
THE FOLLOWING GOT MESSED UP IN POSTING- THE COMMENT BELONGS TO ALEX:
ReplyDeleteI posted a reply to the "Bullocks" video someone has offered in the combox with this link. It was swiftly deleted & I was blocked. http://galileowaswrong.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/Bullocks_Rebuttal-2.pdf I'm sure he's not happy about the fact that most of the material people smugly post is addressed at GWW.
I think it it really interesting. We post everything from our opponents that actually deals with the question.
DeleteOur opponents censor everything we post that actually deals with the question.
Hmmmmm.......